May 19th, 2007
Here in America we make big talk about the freedom of speech and the Internet as a means to equalize all voices. But once again research is showing us that for much of the world that just simply isn’t true. The latest is this article in Dark Reading explaining the forthcoming OpenNetInitiative’s research on how many countries restrict Internet content (25 out of 41 studied).
To be clear, I’m not talking about the kind of network access restrictions that prudent network directors put in place to ensure that people aren’t visiting goatse.cx while they are supposed to be working, I’m talking about blocking everyone in the country from accessing certain content based on political or “moral” decisions made by the regime (or “administration” depending on your point of view) in power.
Now, as a technical matter savvy Internet users will be able to get around these filters without much trouble. So once again, you can’t defeat the geeks. And as a practical matter once the leading edge folks figure out how to do it they’ll make a simplified method for the average folks.
So why, then, do these countries continue in this way? Is it the case that those in power don’t understand the technology, or perhaps they are misled by those who wold benefit by supporting implementation of such a plan? Certainly such hubris requires tons of hardware and software and labor and consulting and bandwidth and … it is a big, expensive effort this stifling of information flowing through the network (just ask any CIO).
In my limited experience of the world, (and to be sure, I’m neither a psychologist nor a persuader) it is easiest to shape someone’s opinion by letting them form their own opinion. To do that you have to enable them to access all of the information about a topic (even if they only access very little of it in reality). You also have to let them decide to dissent, to form their own opinion different from yours if that’s what happens. I guess what I’m describing here is freedom. Freedom of information, freedom to digest that information (think), and freedom to live their lives in response to the truth they find out about this world.
Realistically I suppose that perspective isn’t going to fly very well in places like China and Iran.
Filed under:
The Internet
No Comments »