Ergo, criticism of the 6910p.
November 10th, 2008Where does your lap go when you stand up?
A few weeks ago I was assigned a new laptop at work which is really fast, but horribly, horribly designed. The HP Compaq 6910p … I dub thee: the racing camel.
First, let’s talk about how sweet it is. Intel® Coreâ„¢ 2 Duo Processor T7800 (2.6 GHz, 800 MHz FSB, 4 MB L2 cache), DVD+/-RW SuperMulti with Double Layer, 14.1-inch diagonal WXGA+ anti-glare screen, Type I/II PC card (Which I need for EVDO because even though this laptop is sometimes sold with a Verizon EVDO card built in, my employer didn’t think that was a worthwhile investment for some reason), and an SD card reader which I have yet to use, but probably will.
It also has a whole bunch of stuf that I’ll probably never use:Â Fingerprint reader, SmartCard reader, Firewire port, a third (3!) USB port, modem, s-video … and that’s before we get to the docking station (which is itself a hate-mail from an ergonmic design school dropout).
And even though I’m attached to it at the present moment, I’m going to continue to avoid talking about the docking station because … you know what? This is a laptop; a portable computer. You know what you’re supposed to do with it? Port it! That’s right, travel! So, then, let’s look at my least favorite feature of this laptop when it is being used without the dock: the exhaust vent. You see, that highfalootin’ video subsystem kicks out some real heat, which needs to go somewhere. Preferably away from me, you know?  But I also must confess that my laptops frequently get set down on their edge when I get interrupted mid-use. And doing that with this lappy would cover that exhaust vent, inviting heat problems. I can’t set it down on the opposite edge because that’s where the rj45 ethernet connects. Why? Why not on the back, somewhre near where the power connects? DDFF: design disconnected from function. And function, in this sense, means how it is used, not just what it is supposed to do.
But when I pick the laptop back up, and if I’ve had the absence of mind to close the lid, getting the thing to wake back up is a crapshoot, but if I’ve brushed against the touch-sensitive strip at the top of the keyboard, I’ve either fired up a specialty program, turned on/off the wi-fi, or cranked up or muted the volume. I realize that touch sensitive buttons that aren’t really buttons is all sexxyy this year, and it really is good for some applications, but personal use business machines don’t seem like the place.
And speaking of buttons, there’s no way to do ctrl-alt-del with one hand with this keyboard layout. Believe it or not, this computer is designed to run a Windows operating system, so you’d think you’d be able to perform the #1 Windows key sequence for fifteen years running with just one appendage. I don’t care which, but two hands are not available to lock my screen when I’m running off to a meeting and reaching out for my mug of coffee with one hand as I stand up.
And another thing, don’t make the track pad so (which I hate to use but cannot disable) so sensitive that every time I flick my wrist to use a keyboard shortcut I accidentally change windows and select a paragraph of random text or worse. Or just make the trackpad work sort of decently so you can omit the nipple-pointer in the middle of the keyboard and the additional set of buttons that go along with it. Why is there a gutter around the keyboard, and what are these rubber things sticking up in the middle of it? Two words, fellas: wrist and rest. And resting on the holes where the born-to-break lid clip attaches is not comfortable. It just isn’t.
Is that all? No .. the audio through the built in speakers is awful. I don’t know what the reviewers who liked it were listening to, but if you want to listen to actual music they suck. And when I plug my headphones into the jack the speakers still function. That was an annoying half an hour for the guy in the cube next to mine. I’ve never known a laptop to work that way. Stupid.
Ok, look. you can call me a curmudgeon or a mac fanboy (even the MacBook Pro makes some of these mistakes .. but far fewer), and you would not be completely wrong but not completely right, either.
But since I have a place to rant about it, I will.
Did ya miss me?
Filed under: Computers, gadgetry, Workstation
I expect 